Feedback And Reviews

Hear from writers–just like you–who’ve worked with our agents, editors, authors, and experts.

We’re here to support you every step of the way.

Filter Testimonials

Provides Honest and Enthusiastic Support

My consult with Jonathan Burkhart was amazing! He is direct and knowledgeable and more than willing to guide and support. I absolutely love his energy and enthusiasm. He is honest which Is a trait I respect and was most helpful in his comments to help me become a better writer.
I highly recommend Jonathan Burkhart to any aspiring author who is looking for honest evaluation of your story and the possibility that it could be made into a screenplay.

Anita Sacco
March 24, 2025

Believes in Writers and Their Work

I cannot heap enough praise on Katharine Sands. She deserves more than I can ever say.
First off, Katharine believes in me. Thatís a BIG thing for someone who has been on a publishing journey for a decade. Her enthusiasm and persistent cheeriness is infectious. It makes every session, no matter how brutal, a pleasure. Sheís also not afraid to tell the truth. She delicately convinced me that my opening chapter wasnít appropriate and offered several suggestions on how to fix it while educating me on what a first chapter should be. Katharine also set me up with an online writing class that vastly improved my skills. She continues to seek out further classes for me.
Again, canít say enough about Katharine. A joy to work with.

Kevin McDermott
March 24, 2025

Recognizes and Fixes Story Issues

The discussion I had with Ms. Fountain was extremely useful and informative. She helped me recognize an issue with my YA adventure novel that I need to address and I even had fun during her feedback and suggestions. I can tell she is passionate about her authors’ manuscripts and she would make a great agent for anyone who is lucky enough to sign with her. Thanks for having this service. It is worth the price of admission!

T.R. Foster
March 24, 2025

Enhances Story Openings with Insightful Advice

Kiki is great to toalk to. Even though she had only my first 10 pages, she had some terrific insights, which will enhance the beginning of my story, giving it more punch. Her advice was in point, and noted.

I also get to craft a prologue for my story….YAY!!

Matt Leyshon
March 24, 2025

Energizes Writers with Query Feedback

Stephanie was wonderful. She walked me through specific items to strengthen my query and opening pages while making sure to point out what works. I feel energized to revise my query package after her feedback.

Kerry Chaput
March 24, 2025

Supports Writers in Book-to-Film Adaptation

I signed up for Mr Burkhart because he seemed the most likely to give a good critique for a feature film possibility ó his comments during the #MSWL Zoom panel were pro writer and pro new content and encouraged the audience of writers to consider contributing their content in the new film-media arena.

Jonathan was very cordial and approachable during our conversation. I would book him again.

Thank you to the Julie and Jessica and everyone at the Manuscript Academy for a very informative Book to Film panel!

Angela Paolantonio
March 24, 2025

Strengthens First Pages with Clear Guidance

Stephanie Stein was really helpful with positive suggestions for my first page of a YA historical fiction. She answered my questions with specific answers about character development and quickly engaging the readerís interest. I took lots of notes. Thank you for offering this venue for writers. Iím sure I will signup again!

Elyse Cregar
March 24, 2025

Shares Kind and Specific Query Feedback

My consultation with Kaitlyn was awesome! She was very kind but also gave me specific, actionable feedback that I can get to work on. Highly recommend her!

Kirsten Randall
March 24, 2025

Delivers Helpful and Encouraging Critique

I loved, loved my consultation with Amy! She was extremely helpful with my query feedback, and I will recommend her to everyone!

Layne Beckner Grime
March 24, 2025

Gives Actionable Suggestions for Stronger Openings

Rachel is awesome. She provided me with bite size actionable suggestions that made my opening chapter so much better. So helpful!

Rick Tyson
Rick Tyson
March 24, 2025

Offers Direction and Encouraging Insights

Jessica is warm and friendly. She gave me fabulous advice and went above and beyond what I expected. I know the direction I need to take with my writing now, in large part because of this conversation. Thank you!

Mona Mehas
March 24, 2025

Guides Writers Through Complex Pitches

Caitlin was incredibly helpful. I was struggling with the best way to pitch a fantasy novel that was not told chronologically and she guided me through that process. She answered all my questions and made me feel very comfortable.

Lauren Fitzgerald
March 24, 2025
>