Feedback And Reviews

Hear from writers–just like you–who’ve worked with our agents, editors, authors, and experts.

We’re here to support you every step of the way.

Filter Testimonials

Gives Concrete and Encouraging Feedback

Fiona was exceptional! She gave me concrete, thorough, and kind feedback, truly showing her interest in aiding my writing and my manuscript. Her enthusiasm was encouraging, and she even gave me a tidbit of advice that she typically gives her clients. What a gift to my craft! I highly recommend Fiona.

Shanna Upchurch
March 24, 2025

Answers Common Questions with Clarity

Extremely helpful. she answered questions a lot of us have gotten vague answes to in the past.

Robyn Michaels
March 24, 2025

Gives Insightful and Detailed Guidance

I participated in a small group critique with Jessica Watterson and I was so impressed with the way she made sure to give adequate time to each writer’s query and first page, while also providing general guidance about the querying process. Jessica’s advice was thoughtful and helpful. I found myself taking lots of notes based on what she told others about their queries and pages, as well as her comments on my own.

Anna Mullady
March 24, 2025

Improves Manuscripts with Clear Suggestions

I really appreciate how Aneeka zeroes in on specific, workable suggestions to improve my MS. Having an independent review by an expert such as her raises up items that I as the writer don’t necessarily see. Very helpful!

Rick Tyson
Rick Tyson
March 24, 2025

Plans Next Steps in Publishing

I love Valentina! She is so sweet and sharp! We worked out a plan for the next steps on my publishing journal for my novel. I am excited to speak with her again.!

Mona Mehas
March 24, 2025

Finds New Story Trajectories

John was extremely helpful and helped me see that there is a brand new trajectory I can now focus on for my book. I appreciated his comments and the time he took with me. He saw the story in a different light, a different path and for that I am grateful. I look forward to the next “chapter” in the journey of trying to get an agent for my book.

Stacey Powells Lyster
March 24, 2025

Delivers Spot-On Manuscript Feedback

Fiona Kenshole has a wealth of experience to share. Her advice was spot on, and given in a positive manner. I highly recommend her for Manuscript Academy appointments and events.

Lynn Lovegreen
March 24, 2025

Encourages and Supports Writers

Jessica is SO great. She’s so easy to talk to and has a great sense of humor. She made me feel completely at ease and was very encouraging. Thank you so much for this service!

Jess Haberman
March 24, 2025

Offers Real Advice on Positioning

Jessica was great! She offered real, actionable advice on how to improve my query and offered great insight on the state of publishing, which gave me a great ideas about how to position my book for success.

Jami Sheets
March 24, 2025

Strengthens Queries with Clear Suggestions

Amy was great! She helped me strengthen my query by suggesting changes and answering my specific questions. Perfect!

Mona Mehas
March 24, 2025

Shares Expert Guidance on Structure

Fiona Kenshole is truly the story whisperer. During our meeting, she meticulously went through my first 10 pages and provided in depth details of her critiques. Like Socrates did for Plato, she used the Socratic method to force me to think critically about my characters drawing out the essence of each characterís purpose. She is warm, kind, and pleasant to talk to. If youíre lucky, then youíll get to meet her beautiful 4-month-old Labrador Retriever or Rufus or Grace.

Snarr Barbara
March 24, 2025

Provides Thoughtful Query Review

I booked a 10-minute consultation with Stephanie Winter regarding my query letter. It was a wonderful experience in every way. I have missed being able to attend writing conferences in person and sometimes–okay, more than sometimes–it’s disheartening to get a rejection or to hear nothing from agents I query, particularly when the process feels so impersonal. I much prefer face-to-face interaction and this is as good as it gets for now.

Stephanie was kind and thoughtful in the feedback she provided. I’ve tweaked by query letter accordingly. It’s well worth a small investment to get more insight into whether a query letter is intriguing agents or causing them to quickly press the delete button as though it were a warmup for competing on “Family Feud.” I paid for this consultation as a personal gift last Christmas, a time of year when I can feel generous, even to myself. So glad I did!

Gregory Walters
March 24, 2025
>