Feedback And Reviews

Hear from writers–just like you–who’ve worked with our agents, editors, authors, and experts.

We’re here to support you every step of the way.

Filter Testimonials

CeCe was wonderful! Very warm and encouraging while still zeroing in on precisely what needed fixing in my query letter. She was easy to talk to and I appreciated that she gave options for how we could handle the 10 minutes. Highly recommend!

Teresa Rhyne
March 24, 2025

Renee Fountain is insightful and speaks with a kind but clear voice. She helped me see where I could improve my work, and gave me the confidence to make the needed changes. I left our consultation feeling hopeful, knowing I could and will improve my memoir. I definitely have received the best advice available. I haven’t had a bad consultation since I began with the Manuscript Academy, but Renee has been the best possible choice for me. Thank you.

Shelia Diaz
March 24, 2025

I did a ten minute consultation with Amy regarding my query letter, and while she thought it was good to begin with, she immediately made it better. It’s a subjective business, but getting the perspective of an agent is definitely helpful.

Aimee Fluitt
March 24, 2025

I had a fantastic session with Jennifer Wills. Such great feedback on my first 10 pages and query!
Thank you Jennifer!

Raquel Levitt
March 24, 2025

Cecelia was direct and professional. I worked with her twice, once with a fairly polished query and again with another query consisting of a smattering of disconnected content that I was curious to get an agentís opinion on. She provided excellent feedback and was economical with our brief time together.

Anthony Catalano
Anthony Catalano
March 24, 2025

One of the best consults I’ve had yet with MA! I’ve been waiting for a while to snag CeCe, and it was worth the wait. It helps that my query is “almost there,” and I came away from consult very happy. She actually used the word “perfect” twice: once, in reference to my first qualifying paragraph, and the second time in reference to my last or bio paragraph. She said “don’t change a thing” for those paragraphs. As for the middle two, she asked for more plot points and development, and less characterization and creative writing. She said save that for the novel. I’ve been told this before but don’t know how to execute it. She then suggested how to add more plot without giving away the whole book. Cheers to CeCe!

MaryLou Galyo
MaryLou Galyo
March 24, 2025

My consultations were wonderful! Caitlin was incredibly helpful and the answers she had to my questions assuaged many of my fears and worries. She explained her feedback and suggestions in a clear way that felt achievable. She was friendly and warm. It was a great experience that left me invigorated to revise. =)

Erin Swann
Erin Swann
March 24, 2025

Renee C. Fountain exceeded my expectations both as a person and as an agent. Because of my faulty memory, I got caught up in doing something else and was about 30 minutes late joining Renee online. I immediately apologized for keeping her waiting all that time. At first, she seemed a bit standoffish, but by the time our conversation was over, she had opened to a smiling, pleasant person who projected a sunny, caring personality. The fault was 100% mine, but she said nothing about it. We talked about my work, and though she said up front that the piece wasn’t right for her, she did point out a couple of things I could do to tighten the opening. She complimented my writing and said it had left her wanting more. Her suggestions were couched in a friendly way, with each one making a strong point. The funds were a good investment, and the experience was definitely worth it. Thanks both to the organizers and to Renee. TAG

Thomas Andrew Green
Thomas Andrew Green
March 24, 2025

Marilyn Atlas was a warm, insightful talent manager who quickly enhanced my understanding of my work and offered great suggestions for ensuring potential agents grasped the applicability of my historical fiction for today’s readers.

Sandra Elliot
Sandra Elliot
March 24, 2025

Great help! Mahalo.

James Arlington
James Arlington
March 24, 2025

Melissa got right to business in our short ten minute session. That may be a turn off to some but as I thought about it I realized how professional she was. She gave me her frank opinion on my first pages coupled with my query letter and it all seemed to click. Our short ten minutes together showed she knows how to conduct herself in a frank, business like manner. Even better is the fact that the changes she recommended will surely be implemented as I’m now working on a new starting point for my novel.

Chen Okafor
Chen Okafor
March 24, 2025

I thoroughly enjoyed my consultation with Kaitlyn. She had gone over my page in detail before the meeting and had quite helpful observations. We discussed several questions I had, and I appreciate her input. On top of it all, she was extremely kind and encouraging. She’s a great Faculty Member!

Jane Hershberger
Jane Hershberger
March 24, 2025
>