Feedback And Reviews

Hear from writers–just like you–who’ve worked with our agents, editors, authors, and experts.

We’re here to support you every step of the way.

Filter Testimonials

My meeting with Fiona was very helpful. She nailed exactly what was missing from my first pages and query letter and articulated it in a way that sparked ideas and a course of action. I can see how I can integrate her advice as it was quite specific about what aspects of my first pages and query to put more, or less, emphasis on. I was very happy with the consultation and highly recommend Fiona.

Stephanie Smith
March 24, 2025

I signed up for this consult knowing my query letter wasn’t delivering the punch I wanted. In the fifteen minutes we had together Jenissa broke it down for me pinpointing my weaknesses but also showing me how to fix them – while being friendly and encouraging the entire time. Definitely a great experience.

Eric Ullerich
Eric Ullerich
March 24, 2025

Ms. Strouth was absolutely incredible. Not only vastly knowledgeable about the industry, but also supportive in such a way that her critiques are still presented in a positive light and do not discourage at all. I cannot recommend her enough, she is absolutely brilliant.

Harry Waddington
March 24, 2025

Fiona gave me really great insights into a children’s picture book I was stuck with. Her recommendations helped take the story to the next level. In fact, she helped me find those places where I could elevate it in a way even other reviewers hadn’t seen, and I’m really loving the result!

Sarah Graves
March 24, 2025

I found my consultation with Stacy to be extremely helpful. She asked insightful questions about my story to help clarify a confusing paragraph of my query, and I think my letter is a lot better because of it. She was kind, genuinely seemed interested in my manuscript, and made sure to answer all my questions. I highly recommend meeting with Stacey!

Katie Bono
March 24, 2025

Thank you so much for the opportunity for feedback! This was another useful and productive session. Stephanie Stein gave me concrete, actionable feedback to implement in both my pages and query in an organized fashion. I’m so grateful for the opportunity to speak with her and my previous critique with Blair Thornburgh. Blair’s concise suggestions and Stephanie’s market knowledge and useful notes for my pages and query will help me improve my query package. Thank you for the opportunity to improve my writing with experiences with such seasoned professionals.

Jess Stork Glicoes
March 24, 2025

Fiona Kensole is a kind, positive person who will give you helpful feedback in a constructive way. She is an expert in kid lit.

Lynn Lovegreen
March 24, 2025

Anjanette was very professional but also kind and thoughtful. We had a nice chat, neatly worked in around NINE great tweaks she suggested for my query. It was exactly what I was hoping for.

Kurt Wallace
March 24, 2025

Caitlin was fantastic! Her session started and ended promptly, her passion for my manuscript and query showed, and she provided excellent feedback and ideas to address the issues she uncovered in the first ten pages. Thanks!

K. R. Raye
March 24, 2025

Fiona is such a delightful person! She’s easy to talk to and her personality is effervescent. I felt comfortable and confident throughout our critique. I felt validated and excited to tackle revisions on my informational picture book.

Kelly Kandra Hughes
March 24, 2025

Carina was incredibly helpful in her feedback on my query letter and first ten pages. She was kind and professional and provided specific suggestions that greatly improved my query submission!

Jessica Pateris
March 24, 2025

It was invigorating and motivating to meet with Katie Greenstreet to review my query letter. She was able to give me very specific feedback to strengthen my query letter including an ideas for a better comp and what info to add to the letter for clarity. She also was able to share her thoughts on some specific things that agents are looking for or not looking for in my genre (thriller) which was helpful as I make final decision on the structure of my manuscript. I’m so glad I met with her!

Laura Asrani
March 24, 2025
>