Feedback And Reviews

Hear from writers–just like you–who’ve worked with our agents, editors, authors, and experts.

We’re here to support you every step of the way.

Filter Testimonials

Excited and Energized for Revision

Alyssa was fantastic! She clearly truly read my pages and sincerely thought about them. She asked questions and gave great ideas for revision and sprinkled in plenty of compliments. I left me meet up with her full of renewed energy and excitement for my project.

Megan Persinger
March 24, 2025

Stronger Story Imagery and Feedback

Jennifer was warm, friendly and immediately took the awkwardness out of a call with a stranger, using humor. She then brain stormed ideas for stronger imagery to begin my story and provided concise feedback for a few more tweaks.
The insight gained from an industry professional is well worth the cost. I would definitely recommend the query & 10 pages consult. My manuscript is YA speculative fiction.

Tamara Kahler
March 24, 2025

Practical Query Letter Improvements

Very helpful query review. Many good ideas offered for improvement.
Thank you.

J. Curtis Dailey
March 24, 2025

Guidance to Breathe New Life

Rebecca met me where I was and helped guide me to where I needed to go. She is incredibly knowledgeable and gives wonderful insight. After we got off the call, I felt that there was new life to breathe into this project. I’m grateful and appreciative.

Maria Costanzo Palmer
March 24, 2025

Refining My First Chapter

Linda was very kind and had a nice balance of compliments vs. constructive feedback. We talked about why my first page was almost “there” but not quite. I’m excited to re-work my first chapter with her comments in mind! These sessions are such a great resource for writers. I got exactly the feedback I needed for where I am in the process.

Juliana Clayton
March 24, 2025

Spot-On Query Letter Insights

The ten-minute query consultation with Lizzie Poteet was spot on. She was direct and offered insightful information to bring the query to light. She jumped right in during the phone call and had read the query and had specific questions, which made me think and be visionary. Manuscript Academy is so worth the investment!
Sherry Purdom

sherry purdom
March 24, 2025

Helpful Suggestions and Confidence Boost

I had 10 minute query review with Jessica, and whew were those 10 minutes helpful! To start, she was extremely friendly, warm, and disarming — so helpful when I am a bucket of nerves. Jessica went through my query, offering wonderful suggestions on wording, tweaks, and ways to help my words and message stand out. She was very receptive to my questions and took the time to really understand what it was that I was trying to say with my work. I highly recommend this service, specifically with Jessica. She gave me such helpful feedback on my query letter, making me that much more confident with my query package.

Stephanie Rondeau
March 24, 2025

Pinpointing the Missing Piece

My session with Melissa Warten was extremely helpful! I sent her my query letter for my contemporary YA novel, and her comments and feedback were very insightful. She pinpointed the one detail that was missing from the plot description. It felt like she helped me put the last piece into a puzzle. She was positive and encouraging, but also gave me truly helpful critique.

Karen Trowbridge
March 24, 2025

Invaluable Feedback from an Agent

Awesome experience! I would recommend this service to any and all writer friends because hearing concrete information from an actual agent was invaluable. There is so much guesswork and insecurity that comes with Query letters and submissions. John Cusick was wonderful and gave me incredible feedback in our 10 minute session. Honestly, I wish I would have signed up for this service a year ago! It would have saved me from so much agony and self-sabotage. I was only going to sign up for Manuscript Academy for one month, but now I think I’ll hang around for a while until I’m finished submitting my current project:)

Thanks Guys!!!

Rhianna Helton
March 24, 2025

Transformative Advice for Character Depth

Cecilia totally unlocked me. I was experimenting with some new-to-me techniques and she had insights beyond them that really spiced up what I was trying to do. We talked about active vs passive emotions and figuring out that I needed to open with anger instead of grief and loss has ratcheted my first chapter up 100 degrees in heat. I’m reading the pages now and thinking “wow, I wrote this.” I feel like her tips on how to take a character who is alone and open them up to an interaction, and how to make sure each scene opens in a systematically engaging ways are tips I will use every time I write. LOVE HER.

Alysha Dominico
March 24, 2025

Detailed and Encouraging Query Critique

Caitlin’s critique of my query letter was excellent; she went into depth about what her thoughts were and how to improve each paragraph. She made sure my questions were answered in a calm, quick manner, and was very encouraging.

Madelene Waldron
March 24, 2025

Actionable and Thought-Provoking Guidance

My meeting with Katharine was very insightful, productive and action oriented. Her review and suggestions were specific and thought provoking. I left my meeting recharged from her passion, detail and wealth of knowledge of the publishing world. The Manuscript Academy is a fabulous resource that creates a solid framework for aspiring authors make their voices heard in our transforming world. If you are ready to take your manuscript from paper to people The Manuscript Academy is for you! Glowing bubbles of appreciation.

Melissa Boyd
March 24, 2025
>