Feedback And Reviews

Hear from writers–just like you–who’ve worked with our agents, editors, authors, and experts.

We’re here to support you every step of the way.

Filter Testimonials

I really enjoyed my consultation with Taj. She gave me great feedback to help strengthen the world building for the opening pages of my manuscript!

Jacob Reynolds
March 24, 2025

Anjanette is a really lovely person! She had some very specific and very useful advice, which was great, because I needed that exact critique! Now my query letter is ready to shine.

Sevastian Volkov
March 24, 2025

Adriann’s suggestions for improving my query and opening pages were insightful, and delivered with clarity and kindness. I was able to get right to work on them. I’m very satisfied.

Scarlet Kinney
March 24, 2025

Katharine gave me a good sense of what I need to concentrate on while I revise my proposal and my book.

Nikki Finlay
March 24, 2025

This was the second time I spoke with Chelsey. I feel she’s tough and generous at the same time with her feedback. She will tell you what you need to hear and accentuate the positives she has observed. That has allowed me to pickup on my mistakes and issues throughout my WIP.

Ben Lucas
March 24, 2025

My meeting with Fiona was priceless. Her insight and advice was fantastic. She spent longer than the allotted time, and I truly felt like she cared. I still canít believe I was able to meet with her one on one. Sheís a legend. Wow! Thanks for this opportunity!

Adrienne Deeb
March 24, 2025

Chelsey was great! I worked with a development editor on my book and she never thought of the small but impactful changes Chelsey thought of! I’m so grateful …. this is a great service!
Thank you!
Jayne

Jayne Chase
March 24, 2025

At first, I was hesitant to book a session ó†$100 seemed like so much money for just 15 minutes of face time. But several of my author friends on Instagram had a great experience, so I took the plunge. I’m so glad I did! It wasn’t just the 15 minutes of face time, but the opportunity to have an agent actually review my submission thoroughly in advance so we could have a conversation about it. Dani Segelbaum was so friendly, helpful and encouraging. Her enthusiasm for my query letter and initial pages gave me the confidence I needed to head back into the querying trenches feeling good about my work, and her suggestions for tweaks to make my submission the best it could be were so helpful. She also provided some general suggestions for dealing with the often discouraging query process as well. I would highly recommend Dani and Manuscript Academy for anyone considering a consultation like this.

Cortney Casey
March 24, 2025

Talking with Kaitlyn Sanchez was so delightful I forget that the next day, I would have to drop being a summer writer and go back to being a high school English teacher. Kaitlyn was charming, warm, and encouraging. She had wonderful suggestions that helped me make my query stronger. Even though she doesn’t represent my genre, I wanted to hear her thoughts–because she is such a strong advocate of LGBTQ+ literature. She had wonderful suggestions that helped me make my query stronger, and I was impressed how quickly she “got” what my book was about. I really appreciated her insights.

Edward Jennings
March 24, 2025

Although Dani Segelbaumís vivisection of my query was in-depth, she was so congenial that there was no need for Novocain. She gave me pinpoint suggestions that helped me streamline the pitch and make the prose clearer. An extra set of eyes is invaluable to any writeróespecially when the task is the dreaded query letteróand Daniís perspective allowed me to see the letter as the opening of a dialogue. She is as smart and focused as she is kind.

Bud Jennings
March 24, 2025

Days ahead of my Query + 30-Page Read + 30-Minute Consultation with Eric Smith, he sent me my pages with copious comments. If thatís all I got from Eric, Iíd have been thrilled. His attention to detail, astute insights, and fantastic recommendations helped me tighten and enhance the all-important opening pages. So add the meeting to that, and I felt like I hit the jackpot. He is a really generous, kind, empathetic human being who clearly enjoys helping writers. Eric’s notes offered encouragement; in the meeting, Eric offered warm compassion. He’s just a wonderful human being.

Bud Jennings
March 24, 2025

My consultation with Kelly was fantastic. She helped confirm for me a problem I saw in the work and gave me great advice for moving forward. I came out of the meeting knowing I had a lot of work to do but feeling confident about my project and eager to get back to it.

Adele Liles
March 24, 2025
>