Testimonials And Reviews

Hear from writers–just like you–who’ve worked with our agents, editors, authors, and experts.

We’re here to support you every step of the way.

Filter Testimonials

Maximum density advice

I received an hour’s worth of clarity in just ten minutes. She took a complex, multispecialty book concept and immediately pointed out where my platform needed work and gave me a clear plan. Honest, actionable steps that completely changed how I’m preparing to approach agents. If you want a sharp, real-world perspective on your project, her advice is top-notch.

Duane Penshorn
June 24, 2026

Thorough and Thoughtful!

Kaitlyn’s PB feedback was thorough and thoughtful. She bounced ideas and suggestions & answered manuscript and industry questions! I felt heard and supported as a writer!

Kristina
June 23, 2026

Expert and Generous!

Ivan is an absolute pleasure to work with! I only had a 10-minute appointment with him, yet even in that brief time, his expertise in storytelling, querying, and understanding of current market interests was abundantly clear. He gave me several thoughtful suggestions that meaningfully strengthened my approach and strategy. Ivan is insightful, generous, and genuinely invested in helping writers succeed.

Daniel Polo
June 22, 2026

A fantastic consultation

This was one of the most useful writing consultations that I’ve ever had. Anne Elliot gave me great feedback, and I’m confident that her feedback and suggestions will strengthen my short story. The submission strategy she laid out was tailored to my piece and took so much of the guesswork out of the process for me. I left session feeling energized and supported, genuinely more confident about my next steps.

Susanne Allen
June 22, 2026

Exactly What My Novel Needed

My 15-minute consultation with Katharine Sands was invaluable. In just a quarter of an hour, she identified several ways to strengthen both my query letter and the first ten pages of my novel. Her suggestions—including sharpening my protagonist’s introduction, crafting a stronger opening paragraph, and updating my comp titles—were insightful and immediately useful. I left the conversation energized, encouraged, and with a clear roadmap for revision.

Warren Cook
June 16, 2026

Great feedback and advice for an IP pitch

I met Ivan yesterday, and it was a very positive, inspiring and useful experience – Ivan gave me lots of practical advice and great feedback, and also sent me a list of agents he thinks are perfect for my concept. I’m very happy with the session – it definitely felt like the first day of the rest of my life as a full-time author. Ivan was personal yet professional, and he came well prepared for our meeting. I strongly recommend him to anyone who needs advice on pitching an entire IP.

Camilla Tubertini
June 13, 2026

Helpful, kind and so insightful

I will recommend a session with Taj to anyone struggling in the query trenches! She was so helpful and kind, making the session more fun than I thought a critique would be. Her insight into my story and intention helped me craft my query letter better for my next batch! Thank you Taj!

Samantha Brinson Lee
June 6, 2026

Absolutely worthwhile!

Stephanie was great, very friendly and polite which is always helpful when you’re nervous! She gave me some great pointers. Overall I was very pleased and would definitely recommend her expertise. 😊

KARINA STORER
May 31, 2026

Excellent consultation with Jessica Sinsheimer

Jessica was awesome. She was very thorough with my query letter, giving me feedback on each paragraph. She was spot on with what the query needed. I highly recommend her. Thank you, Jessica and Manuscript Academy! I’ve done a few consultations with you guys and will definitely come back.

Patty Barrue
May 30, 2026

Fruitful Use of Time

Bridget was helpful and provided actionable editorial insights for my pages as well as feedback on my query letter. The psychological comfort of simply getting those materials in front of someone in the industry is of value all on its own, but I appreciated her friendliness and constructive approach to addressing what she noticed. She also shared a few details about the current publishing industry environment from an agent’s perspective which I was interested to hear.

Haley
May 29, 2026

A Much-Needed Recommendation

For my 10-minute meeting, I left it up to Fiona to decide whether we should discuss my query or the first page of my novel. (I really liked the fact that The Manuscript Academy gives the option to let the Instructor decide).
To my surprise, Fiona chose neither in detail, saying both were well done (!). Instead, she asked what had drawn me to write about the topic of my book. Her listening skills put me right at ease.
I had some questions ready, but we focused on this one:
Is my subject matter too difficult/controversial for agents to consider?
Fiona pointed out something I needed to hear before I could move forward with my book. She also offered a practical idea for how to proceed and encourage agents to respond.
For that, I am very grateful.

Kris Doran Williams
May 29, 2026

Exactly the guidance a debut author needs

Erica went through my query paragraph by paragraph and gave me precise, actionable feedback. She spotted immediately that framing the book as ‘first in a planned series’ was weakening my submission, and advised repositioning it as a stand-alone with series potential. She also pushed me to make the protagonist’s personal stakes clearer. It was the kind of specific, craft-focused guidance that’s hard to find elsewhere. Professional, warm, and genuinely useful for a debut author navigating the query trenches.

Hermia Diamanti
May 28, 2026
>