Feedback And Reviews
Excellent feedback on my picture book project.
Not only did Kate give me excellent feedback on my picture book project, her comments were positive and constructive, and let me know exactly where I was on the right (write?) track and what needed more attention. Thank you, Kate and Manuscript Academy!

I had a blast talking to Samantha Wekstein!
I had a blast talking to Samantha Wekstein! She is so fun and had great advice about improving my query. Where else would a budding writer like me have the ability to talk to such a stellar agent? Thank you Manuscript Academy!

The advice concerning my query letter from Melissa was probably the best I have received during my writing career.
The advice concerning my query letter from Melissa was probably the best I have received during my writing career. It was personal, and caring, and my query will be much stronger thanks to her help.
I highly recommend other authors to invest in this consultation.

I am so, so, grateful and delighted.
I was so excited to have a 10 minute call with Caitie because she was one of the agents who liked my #DVPIT tweet back in October. She loved my MC’s voice, which was so affirming for me. Caitie also gave me solid tips to strengthen my opening page.
I’m in the middle of an R&R for another agent, so it really helped when I asked her for tips on that. She helped me see that there really isn’t a ‘time limit’ per se for my R&R. Caitie believes in my story enough to wait for my strongest version, so she’ll wait for me to resubmit my revised first 50 pages to her. I am so, so, grateful and delighted I got to have such a lovely Skype call with her. Thank you, Caitie and Manuscript Academy!

I hope to work with her again in the near future.
Superb experience. Alyssa was knowledgeable, professional and invaluable in sharing guidance with me on publishing, my body of work and strategy for future publication. I hope to work with her again in the near future.

If you’re looking for feedback that will get your manuscript to stick out above the rest, then I definitely recommend signing up for one of these critique sessions.
Molly was incredibly helpful and sweet. If you’re looking for feedback that will get your manuscript to stick out above the rest, then I definitely recommend signing up for one of these critique sessions. I came away from the phone call with a couple of really insightful tips, and I look forward to seeing how my manuscript does in the year.

It’s the best money I’ve ever spent!

I’m so pleased to see it all coming together now in a much stronger query that more clearly conveys the heart of my book.
John critiqued my opening pages, and I was so impressed, I decided to hire him to critique my query. His feedback, along with the feedback I received from other Manuscript Academy faculty, was so insightful. I’m so pleased to see it all coming together now in a much stronger query that more clearly conveys the heart of my book. Thank you so much, John! And thank you, Manuscript Academy, for having such an incredible faculty!

Great 10 minutes with Rebecca Raskin! She was personable, professional, encouraging, and gave me valuable insights on platform-building, comp titles and networking opportunities, and advice on balancing personal story with prescriptive/informational elements to maintain an emotional connection with readers for a non-fiction project. One of the best 10 minutes I’ve spent in professional development as a writer. The Manuscript Academy and their faculty are great resources!
She commented on things I’d never even considered and offered guidance on how to move forward with the changes.
Stephanie gave me so many solid insights into how to make my query solid. She commented on things I’d never even considered and offered guidance on how to move forward with the changes.
She offered clear explanations for why certain things weren’t working and also offered plenty of praise for things that were.
Stephanie is very engaging, and I felt fully at ease talking to her. I highly recommend booking her for a consultation.

She asked insightful questions, gave excellent advice on my query, and I felt like I was chatting with a new friend who genuinely wanted me to succeed.
My consultation with Kimberely Atkins was FABULOUS! She asked insightful questions, gave excellent advice on my query, and I felt like I was chatting with a new friend who genuinely wanted me to succeed and wanted to help me as much as possible.
Thank you!

It was not only helpful, but a confidence boost that I’m on the right path.
Andrea was absolutely fantastic to speak to regarding my query letter. She had some wonderful insights that you can’t find from google and she was joy to speak to. Very warm and personable! It was not only helpful, but a confidence boost that I’m on the right path.

© 2016-2025 The Manuscript Academy, LLC