Feedback And Reviews

Hear from writers–just like you–who’ve worked with our agents, editors, authors, and experts.

We’re here to support you every step of the way.

Filter Testimonials

Insightful encouraging informative

Jennifer was wonderful! She was insightful, encouraging, and informative. I left with a clear idea of what to do to improve my query and manuscript.

Emily Brooks
Emily Brooks
January 17, 2023

New inspiration

I just finished my 10min consult with Jessica as part of my gold membership and it was amazing! She was able to help me get through a plot issue that I had been struggling with and even gave me some new inspiration. I can’t wait to put all the pieces together and share this story.

Laura Millar
Laura Millar
January 13, 2023

Fantastic

It was great.  The advice was fantastic.

Cynthia Webb
Cynthia Webb
January 13, 2023

So helpful

Bibi was so helpful! She helped me fine-tune my query letter and was a pleasure to chat with!

Deborah Norkin
Deborah Norkin
January 13, 2023

Amazing feedback

I’ve been wanting to do an agent one-on-one for quite some time now, and I finally committed. It was so much more than I’d ever hoped for! The 15 minutes flew by, but in that time, Fiona Kenshole gave me some amazing feedback on my first two chapters, things I never even thought of. I’m energized to put her suggestions in motion, see how it flows, and then I’ll be ready to start querying!

Suzy Feine
Suzy Feine
January 11, 2023

Thoughtful and honest

My query letter review with Alyssa Jennette was fantatastic. She was laid back and kind and helpful. She listened to my questions and gave thoughtful, honest answers. It was one of those meetings that proves how much you can accomplish in ten minutes with the right person in the room.

Rachel Frederick
Rachel Frederick
January 11, 2023

A dream to work with!

Stephanie was lovely! Her feedback was efficient, constructive, and professional. I really appreciated how she addressed larger themes (voice) while also digging in at the line-level to really improve my first 250 words. I absolutely recommend her consultations. She was a dream to work with!

Emily Holewczynski
Emily Holewczynski
January 11, 2023

Detailed suggestions

Amy was absolutely wonderful.  Understood my family saga genre completely, has read all my comps and gave me detailed suggestions for tightening up my query and answered all my questions. 

Virginia Stanley
January 11, 2023

Feel much more focused

I had a great meeting with Renee on Sunday. Thank you! I began revising immediately after meeting with her. I feel like I was spinning a bit on where and what I needed to revise, and I feel much more focused now and am enjoying the revision process again.

Irene Lee
Irene Lee
January 11, 2023

Direct and concrete

Katie gave me direct and concrete feedback that, at first, I didn’t want to hear. But as I thought about it, and imagined how I could revise my opening scenes based on her feedback, I realized it was transformative. Now, although it means I have to re-write my opening again, I am confident this time it will be so much better. And the entire story will be as well.

Kristen Crusoe
January 10, 2023

Professional

Lovely, professional, knowledgeable, encouraging

Cynthia Webb
January 10, 2023

Jumpstarted my creativity

Savannah was pleasant and professional. She gave me insight into a structural problem that I very much appreciate. It jumpstarted my creativity and got my story “unstuck”. Thank you!

Laura Smith
Laura Smith
January 10, 2023
>